Score on an inside the park home run while playing at Polo Grounds. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game or by switching teams.)
Win a game in Retro Mode. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, by switching teams, or setting innings to less than 9.)
Hit a home run that travels a minimum of 430 ft in Retro Mode. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game or by switching teams.)
Strike out your opponent on a no swing strike three. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, by switching teams, or with quick counts turned ON.)
Complete a Retro Mode game with the 8-bit filter turned ON. (This trophy is not awarded if completed by using fast forward or setting innings to less than 9.)
With the same player, strike out, then hit a home run in their next at bat. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, or by switching teams.)
With a position player on the mound, strike out a batter. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, by switching teams, or with quick counts ON.)
While batting with your pitcher, get a hit against an opposing pitcher who has the same name. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, or by switching teams.)
On defense, successfully throw out a baserunner that is stealing. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, or by switching teams.)
Complete a game while using the MLB Network® broadcast theme style. (This trophy is not awarded if completed by fast forwarding, using quick manage, or setting innings to less than 9.)
Discover a new end of game celebration by winning as the home team on defense in one of eighteen stadiums. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, by switching teams, or fast forwarding.)
In Franchise, Season, or Postseason™ modes, complete a Quick Manage game. (This trophy is not awarded if completed by entering the game or simulating a half inning.)
In Franchise/Season, complete a game while using Player Lock. (This trophy is not awarded if completed by switching teams, fast forwarding, or disabling player lock.)